The Debate of PhotoReading Against Reading Genius
by youngprer
In Episode II:Attack of the Clones, we see more of the Jedi and the entire interpretation of the "dark side." Now, while my original "Can Jedi PhotoRead?" topic was about that specific question, this topic will mostly more talk about the comparison of PhotoReading to the infamous speed reading course Reading Genius.
PhotoReading can be considered the Jedi, from my point of view, and Reading Genius the Sith. Throughout films such as The Empire Strikes Back, Return of the Jedi, and Attack of the Clones, we see the way a particular character: Yoda describes and proves what the dark side is. It claims to be more powerful, but in reality is merely quicker, seductive, and the easier path.
Reading Genius is the QUICKER, EASIER path!
Now, I would like to ask all experienced Jedi here, to read this entire page, and then take either the Advanced or Super Challenge tests. Watch as the dark side is crushed, and how you "discover" just how much Reading Genius would benefit you.
http://www.readinggenius.com/speed_reading_test/index.php
Throughout the site, Ed Strachar's picture is displayed with what looks like a third of a smile. He looks evil. 
Back to the point! In their comparison of Reading Genius to PhotoReading, they remarkably state several things that simply are not true. (http://www.readinggenius.com/comparison.php)
"When you need to remember and use what you read, you are supposed to go deep in your unconscious and find it. Ugh??? That’s where this system breaks down for the average or even above average person...it’s not very pragmatic."
Ohhh, OKAY, SURE, YEAH.
"Few people master at it and your average student or professional needs real results right away...not abstract ideas that may kick in later. PhotoReading also has a very strong New Age slant that puts off many people, even those who are generally open to new ideas."
PhotoReading is not one bit New Age, as everyone here knows. Abstract ideas are non-existent, and if anything the knowledge obtained from PhotoReading and activating material kicks in heavier and sooner than anything else!
"Founder Paul Sheele's style is such that it can sometimes conflict with people who want pragmatic results and straight forward answers without having to get into abstract terms like 'connect with your subconscious...by closing your eyes and relaxing and see yourself learn faster while listening to low budget spacy music!'"
Okay, two things! Paul has NEVER said that. Ask him! lol And another thing:it's not abstract to even say something that's related to that topic the way we talk about it here. We give true, intelligent, and proven explanations and many scientists, experts, and people in general can relate to. Straight foward answers are ALL PhotoReading offers. If anything, Reading Genius gives abstract impressions with their "accelerative learning music," which only serves as a crutch.
"The use of music , mind mapping and brain states shows the developers of the system understand accelerated learning to a certain degree but something is lost in the delivery and implementation."
PLEASE! You people over there with Eddy boy probably don't even know what that something that is supposedly missing IS! Is that accelerative music and that incredibly intelligent physical exertion the thing that's missing?
"Trainers on photoreading courses often have only taken a home study course or are classed as 'certified trainers' after completing a 2 week course. This can cause quality of trainers to vary significantly. Relative amateurs can give the illusion of knowing what they are talking about when in reality they are usually a lot less confidence in both themselves and the course."
HA! There's a reason they're known as CERTIFIED TRAINERS. And FYI: the experienced PhotoReaders, the instructors, and coaches all have full confiences in ourselves and the course. We know that it works.
"The right music can both facilitate the right brainwaves, balance the left and right brain and make the environment more enjoyable. The wrong music can cause distraction and/or get the brain in the wrong rhythm even though it may sound good. "
Okay, this may be true, but just how are we doing to use this?! It's ridiculous. And many people who have used both Reading Genius, and PhotoReading report that RG is almost a copy of PhotoReading, with minor;uneccesary changes.
And this genius Ed Strachar - showing 5-8 books and saying "read all these within a week!" Yeah?! I read around 15-20 books a week with PhotoReading, how do you like that?!
"Here's a quick and fun way to discover just how much Reading Genius can help you improve your reading speed, comprehension and recall."
PhotoReaders:don't waste much time with those tests. You'll ace them easily, as I did!
In an earlier topic, also note that this great man:Ed Strachar fails to share about how he attended a PhotoReading seminar himself! Search for the topic where Dana talks about this.
Many users of this course say that its methods are ridiculous and completely ineffecient.
Ed Strachar, in my eyes, is the evil Darth Sidious. (The Emperor.) His students are the dark lords of the Sith. PhotoReaders, the real reading genius's, even more credit going to Paul Scheele, and Pete Bissonette.
Throughout many skims of topics, Reading Genius has appeared with people asking questions about the two courses. Well now, I plan to settle this with this topic!
Thank you,
youngprer
(For more information on Reading Genius, look at www.readinggenius.com, its official website.)
[This message has been edited by youngprer (edited May 20, 2002).]
)
So I spell it Australian (note aussies only use one 'l' and it seems Americans spell it with 2 as I learnt from another post)