I am a Martial Artist, with a black belt in Tae Kwon Do and working on my brown belts in Shotokan (Midwest) and Goju Ryu( East Coast), depending on which coast I am on. Most relevant is I have survived several deadly street encounters in my younger days in a rough New York neighborhood and presently protect my clients from violence, in rough inner city neighborhoods.
I find I can use PR for MA, the same way I use PR for calculus, anatomy, and/or physics assignments.
You have to do the hands on work to analyze and identify things, but PR makes getting through the theory and readings easier.
I have been in MA for over 30 years and grew up in a very very rough neighborhood and really find Marc MacYoung's works to be realistic and among the very best. Also Richard Heckler, George Leonard, and Kristie Kilgore have great works to PR, if you don't have time to really digest and read then carefully. Mr. Heckler and Mr. Leonard specialize in Aikido! Richard Heckler has worked intensively with urban street gangs, Green Berets, and Navy Seals Units, and gained the respect of such diverse groups! Last but not least, Kristie Kilgore is a real practicing bodyguard with black belts in Tae Kwon Do, Hawrang Do, and Gracie Jiu Jitsu, but with a great loving heart and Christian background, and understands real life and death encounters.
To answer your question
YOU CAN NOT LEARN MA from just photoreading alone
but photoreading and direct learning make it so much faster.
Actually, I tried a new technique, I had photoread only
and while doing free sparring (randori), recently,
I found myself using the technique by INSTINCT!
Would that work in a real life or death encounter?!
I don't know? I hope I never have to find out.
Good luck,
[This message has been edited by raleigh199 (edited July 27, 2005).]